Before I begin, this is a LONG post. Rather than split it over two days, I’m posting it as a single piece today for those who might prefer to not interrupt the flow. Needless to say, I won’t be posting tomorrow. To help, I have marked a breakpoint if you would prefer to read it in two parts. You can, of course, now listen to it instead using the new audio play button above.
In the febrile environment of US politics and the political shakeup in Washington right now, it’s easy to lose sight of the threat that Trump’s deadly foreign policy has posed around the world. As we move into what is likely to be the most combative lame duck session in modern history, Republicans have a choice to make. They can either continue to cower in a corner and enable Trump further, or they can have a road-to-Damascus moment and face the reality that unless they leave Trumpism behind, they too will fall victim to the political extinction-level event that began on November 3rd.
I think what we are about to see is Trump pushing the envelope further than ever before, because he’s facing a level of legal jeopardy he’s never faced before. The problem he has is that there are no boundaries when it comes to self-enrichment and preservation. Not only does he not give a damn about the American people, he also doesn’t give a damn about anybody or anything, including the Republican Party.
As far as the Senate is concerned, I’d say it’s lost to Republicans until at least 2030, and as for the House, the losses they’ve just sustained are truly historic. As a result, choices must be made: if they think they can begin to recover in 2028 with more of the same, they’re out of their minds. They poked a sleeping giant in November, and that giant made itself heard loud and clear. The silent majority didn’t just speak; they screamed for change.
The political class on both sides of the aisle has been selectively deaf for so long that I fear they no longer know the difference between right and wrong. The everyday citizen is simply expected to accept that politicians know what’s best for them. What really sickens me is that Democratic leadership spent money to stop ‘people first’ candidates from ever having a voice. In what world is that representation of the people? I can talk about this until I’m blue in the face; I fear it will make little difference, but I do know that the collective outrage corporate Democrats are being subjected to has not gone unheard.
One thing that’s been on my mind for a day or so is the resurfacing argument about Chorus-funded liberal influencers. Especially given the media focus on Democratic leadership and, in particular, the softening position on Hakeem Jeffries as House Speaker. It may be that I’ve become paranoid after the election, having heard the clear, outspoken views of so many who seem to be questioning Jeffries’ suitability for the role, especially given his staunch advocacy for Israel and the AIPAC money he’s received.
It just seemed odd to me that some who had advocated for a change in House leadership were suddenly falling in line. It might just be me, but something has felt off. Having said all that, he is, as things stand, unopposed, so the debate is moot as things stand. I’m not here to point fingers or call people out, because what money people accept from whoever is a matter between them and their conscience. It’s easy to be an armchair critic, but I know many content creators work long hours for little reward; I’ve got the T-shirt to prove it. Making a living from content creation is impossible for the vast majority, so when someone comes along offering a regular income to keep doing what you love and already do, what’s not to like?
Where the Chorus thing falls down for me is the lack of transparency. Where does the money come from? I’m old enough and wise enough to know that no money in politics is free money. Nobody should know that better than those who live in the land of the free, where NOTHING is free. I’ve long advocated for better-organised Democratic messaging, and I still believe that in the world we are forced to inhabit, it’s never been more important than it is right now.
The Chorus argument for paying influencers is, in my mind, sound; it provides much-needed financial help and support to a group of influencers who are important voices in advancing progressive political messaging. I’m all in on that mission. The problem for me only arises when the initiative’s funding can be called into question. It’s the old ‘live by the sword, die by the sword’ argument.
I’d simply suggest they declare they are sponsored by Chorus, because that seems to me to be the right thing to do. I understand why they don’t, and it’s because of the contract they signed with Chorus. I suspect that if they declared that fact, it might devalue their message and defeat the whole point of the exercise. I do understand the dilemma.
I’ve been working on the Truth Matters Project with Anthropic’s Claude. I knew that, given the animosity toward AI, it would draw criticism. I decided, however, that I could make a case for why it was important to a project I believe serves the greater good. With that in mind, I placed transparency at the forefront of my work on it, and I remain very comfortable with my decision. Will it cost some support? I expect so, but that’s a fair price to pay for being honest about using it.
I think we can all agree: dark money in politics is a cancer eating democracy from the inside out. With that in mind, I thought I’d take a moment to look at the recent history of this kind of funding. Maybe the right place to start is: what exactly is ‘dark money’? For this, I think this guide from OpenSecrets is a good place to start.
“Dark money” refers to spending meant to influence political outcomes where the source of the money is not disclosed.
It’s not complicated: it’s money pumped into the political conversation to influence public opinion and drive a political narrative that supports the aims of those investing. In the real world, we’d call it a BRIBE. In politics, it’s simply labelled as support. Buying influence in politics is as old as time itself; it’s nothing new.
As with all things connected to the pursuit of power, the best approach seems to be to dress it up in a suit of credibility. Politicians went a step further and wrote it into law. It’s the American way.
OpenSecrets notes:
Politically active nonprofits such as 501(c)(4)s are generally under no legal obligation to disclose their donors even if they spend to influence elections. When they choose not to reveal their sources of funding, they are considered dark money groups.
Opaque nonprofits and shell companies may give unlimited amounts of money to super PACs. While super PACs are legally required to disclose their donors, some of these groups are effectively dark money outlets when the bulk of their funding cannot be traced back to the original donor.
Of course, the latter paragraph points to the green light provided by the 5–4 Supreme Court ruling in 2010 (Citizens United v. FEC), which struck down restrictions on independent political expenditures by corporations, labour unions, and other organisations. The ruling invalidated parts of the previous Bipartisan Campaign Reform Act (BCRA) of 2002, along with earlier precedents set in part by McConnell v. Federal Election Commission in 2003.
If you want to take a closer look at the ruling, I’ve linked it here. More importantly, I would point you to this excellent article by the Brennan Center for Justice, written by Daniel I. Weiner. It was originally published on December 12, 2019, and later updated on January 29, 2025.
For context, Daniel serves as Senior Counsel for the Brennan Center’s Democracy Program, where he works on money in politics, ethics, and other democracy reform issues, including redistricting and fair courts. In the article, he noted:
Justice Anthony Kennedy wrote for the narrow majority that limits on independent spending from corporations and other outside groups equate to limiting their speech and thus violate the First Amendment. This ruling doubled down on a 1976 decision, Buckley v. Valeo, which was the first case to say that campaign expenditures, or money spent to influence voters, was a type of “speech” and that the only permissible justification for most limits on money in politics was to prevent outright bribery, or as the Court’s opinion called it, “quid pro quo corruption.”
The justices who decided Citizens United held that independent spending could not pose a substantial risk of corruption on the erroneous assumption that the money wouldn’t be under the control of any single candidate or party. They also assumed that existing transparency rules would require all the new spending they were permitting to be fully transparent, allowing voters to appropriately evaluate the messages targeting them.
It was effectively a green light by the highest court in the land to subvert democracy, which, in my view, has led us to where we are today. It allowed US politics to become a retail outlet at which corporate America could purchase influence. Then there’s the political Chicken Ranch, where legislative hookers offer their services to the highest bidder.
For me, there’s little doubt that the ruling was a turning point in American politics, codifying the ludicrous assertion that money is free speech. So why is it important in the context of the funding of liberal content creators? It’s vitally important because it speaks to the convergence of dark money being used by BOTH parties. I believe this is one of the major reasons the voting public has sent a message that enough is enough. It speaks to why Democrats remain as submerged in the public trust deficit as Republicans. It’s why Democrats MUST prove they are listening and not just paying lip service to the vociferous concerns of the American people.
For context, prior to 2010, election spending was tightly controlled. For example, 501(c)(4) nonprofits could run ‘issue ads’, but could not spend money to directly support campaigns. It was an important limitation. The ruling assumed transparency would follow. We all know what assumptions deliver, and predictably in politics, transparency soon disappeared.
In a later ruling by the US Court of Appeals for the DC Circuit (SpeechNow.org v. FEC), opacity followed. This ruling stated that groups that spend only on independent expenditures can take donations of any size. Say hello to the birth of the Super PAC. The primary vehicle for opaque donations was born. A Super PAC can take donations of any size from a 501(c)(4) nonprofit. The only obligation is to name the nonprofit as the donor. Meanwhile, the donors to the nonprofit remain anonymous. It’s like a political magic act.
This is a good rest point if you want to read the conclusion later
It has to be said that the anonymity rule for donors to 501(c)(4) nonprofits was challenged later in 2010 by the DISCLOSE Act (Democracy Is Strengthened by Casting Light On Spending in Elections). Might I suggest there’s no better reminder of the danger identified 16 years ago than today’s events. As with most attempts to shine a light on the dark arts of politics, it never became law. It passed the House in June 2010, but in July, a Senate vote to end the filibuster fell three votes short, so the bill died in the Senate. Every Republican voted against it. Further attempts have been made since, but each has failed in the same Senate graveyard.
Following the 2010 ruling, conservative dark money groups were outspending liberal voices by 11:1, according to Issue One. It should be noted that they attribute their figures to the Center for Responsive Politics, which merged with the National Institute on Money in Politics to form OpenSecrets. By 2016, they noted that liberal groups had stepped into the dark money game, spending $37.8 million, but this was dwarfed by conservative dark money spending, which was close to four times the amount at $143.7 million.
Following Trump’s arrival in the Oval Office in 2017, Issue One reported that by the 2018 midterms, the dark money spending picture had inverted, coming in at roughly $81 million for liberal groups and $46.5 million for conservative groups. It had moved from 11:1 in favour of conservatives to 2:1 in favour of liberals. It’s pretty clear that liberals had decided that what was good for the goose was good for the gander. One point worth noting about 2018 is that Majority Forward was a 501(c)(4) nonprofit, linked to the Chuck Schumer-aligned Senate Majority PAC. This is the main Democratic Super PAC that backs Democrats in Senate races. It’s the same dark money vehicle noted above. In 2018, Majority Forward alone accounted for about $1 of every $3 spent by all dark money groups.
By the time we arrived at the 2020 elections, liberal dark money groups spent half a billion dollars compared to $200 million from their conservative counterparts. To read more, feel free to read this piece by Sara Swann from The Fulcrum, quoting figures from OpenSecrets. $61 million of this dark money spending was from the Sixteen Thirty Fund, based on a review of FEC records by the Center for Responsive Politics (OpenSecrets). This is where the Chorus link first appears. The Sixteen Thirty Fund, a 501(c)(4) nonprofit, was Chorus’s financial and legal home for 2025. It was NOT Chorus’s funder; it was simply the conduit through which funding flowed to liberal content creators via anonymous donations. The Sixteen Thirty Fund could legitimately claim they were “not the original source of financing” for Chorus.
On January 1st 2026, Chorus moved away from The Sixteen Thirty Fund to a new entity called the Creator Collective, a DC nonprofit that, once again, has no obligation to disclose its donors. And so we come full circle, in which dark money has funded liberal creators.
I have long advocated for consistent messaging, and that appears to be Chorus’s genuine aim, which I applaud. What I do have a problem with is that I’ve seen people in the group attack those who have had the audacity to ask where the money comes from. There seems to be a tribal approach to isolating and targeting anyone who dares to ask a completely legitimate question. I don’t delve into the merits of petty squabbles; I have no interest in them, but it’s clear it’s got pretty ugly.
For anyone interested, the original piece by Taylor Lorenz, which appeared in Wired on August 27th 2025, did raise some uncomfortable questions that irritated a number of creators who benefited from the project. The piece notes:
The contracts reviewed by WIRED prohibit standard partnership disclosures, declaring that creators will “not publicize” their relationship with Chorus or tell others that they’re members of the program “without Chorus’s prior express consent.” (A screenshot from a slideshow was shared with WIRED following this article’s publication by Graham Wilson, a lawyer working with Chorus, that offers several talking points if a member of the cohort wanted to discuss Chorus publicly.) They also forbid creators from “disclos[ing] the identity of any Funder” and give Chorus the ability to force creators to remove or correct content based solely on the organization’s discretion if that content was made at a Chorus-organized event.
The obvious question is, ‘Why the secrecy and exercise of control?’ More concerning for me was this section:
“There are some real great advantages to … housing this program in a nonprofit,” Wilson said to creators on a Zoom call reviewed by WIRED. “It gives us the ability to raise money from donors. It also, with this structure, it avoids a lot of the public disclosure or public disclaimers—you know, ‘Paid for by blah blah blah blah’—that you see on political ads. We don’t need to deal with any of that. Your names aren’t showing up on, like, reports filed with the FEC.” (Wilson did not reply to a request for comment before the article was published.)
In response, Brian Tyler Cohen, Chorus’s co-founder, disputed WIRED’s summary of the programme (paid to push the party line, kept secret, with restrictions on content), saying: “Literally nothing in this statement is true.” (Mediaite, 29 August 2025)
It’s worthy of note that the House Oversight Committee (subpoena letter, 14 May 2026) shows that clause 4(b) of Chorus’s creator agreements contains a mutual nondisclosure term barring disclosure to third parties “unless such disclosure is required by a valid law or legal process.” While I’m no fan of the chair of this committee, I think it does seem to reflect details mentioned in the contracts seen by Wired.
Again, to be clear, as far as I can see, no laws have been broken, but it does put creators in a very difficult position. They are effectively forbidden from disclosing information about the organisation and its funding. This might well have led to the awkward conversations the group have found themselves facing. Especially if they have spent time advocating for the removal of dark money in politics. It becomes a hard position to defend when you’re a recipient of said dark money.
One is forced to ask serious questions when looking at the 2024 election dark money numbers, which show $1.9 BILLION spent by dark money groups on BOTH sides, with $1.2 billion of that spend coming from groups backing Democrats, according to the Brennan Center. Over a billion dollars in anonymous dark money. Might I be so bold as to suggest Democrats immediately stop throwing stones in glass houses?
So here’s my conclusion: there is no smoking gun here, as some would have you believe. There’s no case to support that argument. I wanted to do this research for my own peace of mind, and hopefully it might help others make an objective judgment when reading or hearing critical narratives surrounding the group. My observations are as follows: my concerns aren’t about creators being paid; God knows, I’m one of them, and I’m not a hypocrite. I know what it costs to research and produce content, and it’s NOT cheap to do it properly.
It’s not my job to judge fellow creators, but it is my obligation to lay out the facts so that people can decide for themselves if trust has been broken. The problem is that it forces me to question everything if dark money is influencing the content of those we thought we could trust to tell us the truth. It’s not encouraging to note that, when asked simple questions about where the money came from, the questioner appears to be ostracised.
For the record, I have long proved I don’t care if my work makes people uncomfortable. I say it as I find it and would never embark on a piece like this without having carefully researched the subject. The uncomfortable truth often finds me on the wrong side of those with an agenda. That’s why The Truth Matters Project is so important to me. I believe that the truth should NEVER be held hostage behind a paywall. Funding my work helps keep it free for those who can’t contribute. That’s how we roll in this community of truth seekers.
You can learn more about the project in the linked piece below. Please note the piece is from October 17th, so things have moved on a little since then. If you’d like to sign up for updates on the project and private previews of new functions as I work toward the official public release on the day the 120th Congress is seated, please click here. You can also visit the live sites using the following links below:
MATTER OF RECORD | TRUTH MATTERS
When the election is over we need a plan
Please note that this post is two pieces rolled into one because I won’t have time to create a separate post on Monday. I’ve indicated where people can stop by and pick up the rest when they have a moment. If you have the Substack App, you can listen on the go.
Next time, we’ll look at the best way for Democrats to navigate the next two years, building momentum toward what I believe could be a supermajority to deliver truly transformative change in 2028.






We will have to fight harder and longer for transparency. Once we achieve it, we can build a system from the ground up that is literally for and by the people. We will be wandering blindfolded otherwise.
Concur. for me, transparency is the first step. every single thing needs to be transparent. that is law for me that is missing. Ideally a clean up of laws that have been abused needs to occur also ie end citizens united, end profiting off position etc..but the revolving door between govt and lobby needs to be destroyed completely. Now we know the oligarchy and big corporations only seek to influence dishonourably, laws need to be in place that are explicit - else they just get around loop holes. -- The system is broken, rigged. So tweaks and twats wont do it. When trust has been obliterated, it is only rebuilt step by step via transparency. Where we the people can see day after day they are being listened too...